What Was the ADM Jabalpur Case? On 25 June , Prime Minister Indira Gandhi invoked Article and imposed a state of Emergency. Hans Raj Khanna (3 July – 25 February ) was an advocate, jurist and judge. While the Habeas Corpus case is Justice Khanna’s most celebrated ruling, .. “A.D.M. Jabalpur vs Shukla: When the Supreme Court struck down the . PETITIONER: ADDITIONAL DISTRICT MAGISTRATE, JABALPUR Vs. .. The Act in the present case is valid law and it has laid down procedure of applying the.

Author: Zologul Bramuro
Country: Zambia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Automotive
Published (Last): 19 February 2008
Pages: 297
PDF File Size: 17.84 Mb
ePub File Size: 12.62 Mb
ISBN: 944-5-61630-632-7
Downloads: 55561
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Digar

On 24 Aprilseven out of 13 judges held that Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution was limited. Bhagwati has arrived at the same conclusion, which is that the writ of habeas corpus is not maintainable in case of proclamation of emergency under article 1 which states Where a Proclamation of Emergency is in operation, the President may by order declare that iabalpur right to move any court for the enforcement of such of the fundamental rights conferred by Part III except Article 20 and 21 as may be mentioned in the order and all proceedings pending in any court for the enforcement of the rights so mentioned shall remain suspended for the period during which the Proclamation is in force or for such shorter period as may be specified in the order.

After completing his schooling from D. Banerji Mirza Hameedullah Beg P.

ADM Jabalpur vs Shivkant Shukla (1976) 2 SCC 521

Chadrachud overruled a judgment authored by his father Justice Y. He wrote in his dissenting opinion:. Additionally, the State just holds the privilege to arrest if the supposed act falls under Section 3 of MISA and its each condition is satisfied.

Shantaram Shivkumar Sharma Umayalpuram K. In the event jaballpur any condition is unfulfilled then detention is past the powers of State.

It was further put forward that the very objective of the Presidential order under Article was to curb legal problems and that it was simpler to make laws against fundamental rights. Inthe Supreme Court constituted its largest ever bench of 13 judges to decide whether Parliament had the unfettered right to amend the Constitution or not.

Archived from the original on 23 August Men have readily laid down their lives at its altar, in order to secure it, protect it and preserve it. Archived from the original PDF on 27 February But I do not think it would be right for me to allow my love of personal liberty to cloud my vision or to persuade jabalppur to place on the relevant provision of the Constitution a construction which its language cannot reasonably bear. Ramanathan Raja Ramanna Caze. Inthe Justice HR Khanna committee was constituted by jbaalpur railway ministry with the mandate of “reviewing the implementation of previous accident inquiry committees, of examining the adequacy of existing practices for safe running of trains and to suggest safety measures.


The family hailed from a trading tradition, but Hans’s father had become a leading lawyer and later, the mayor of Amritsar. Incomparable Court went ahead to expand the elucidation of Article 21 and acquainted Public Interest Litigation with increase open authenticity after it confronted feedback over the judgment and harm it had done.

In para of jwbalpur judgment,Justice D.

Just the boldness of single judge is said to be worth perusing and it was in consonance with humanity, freedom and liberty. The submission of an independent judiciary to absolutist government is virtually the last step in the destruction of a democratic society; and the Indian Supreme Court’s decision appears close to utter surrender.

In this case the four judges Chief Justice A. I have prepared my judgment, adj is going to cost me the Chief Justice-ship of Jabalupr.

In Khanna was nominated for President of India, as a combined opposition candidate supported by as many as nine opposition parties. State of Keralawhich curtailed Parliament’s seemingly unfettered amending power under articlerestricting its scope of amendment in areas which were part of the Constitution’s “basic structure”. Inhe was awarded the Padma Vibhushanthe second highest civilian honour given by the Government of India.

Hans Raj Khanna 3 July — 25 February was an advocatejurist and judge.

Hans Raj Khanna – Wikipedia

Gill Hafiz Mohamad Ibrahim H. Writing a concurring opinion with the majority, Justice Y. Let us take a case where a detenu has been detained in violation of the mandatory provisions of the Act.

He resigned from its chairmanship in when he was inducted into the cabinet as Union Law Minister by Charan Singh. Articles and have not been summoned since repudiation of Proclamation of Emergency in and in mid Due to restraining her political power by jabzlpur Apex court made her dysfunctional in a matter of vote or speak in Lok Sabha.


Khanna, went on to become Chief Justices. Bhagwatiagreed with the governmental view that even the fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution of India like the right to life stood abrogated during the period of national caze.

At the time when Jabalpurr was proclaimed, this writ was not considered as a fundamental right under article 21 remained suspended.

In State of Uttar Pradesh v. In fact, when the counsel for the people argued by citing the example of the genocide of the Jews at the hands of Hitler and how, if the decision is given in favor of the petitioner, will give rise to a similar scenario, was scolded and ridiculed by C. At one point in the chapter he says of Justice Khanna, “his statue must be installed in every street and corner of the country for the yeoman service rendered by him for the cause of justice”. Khanna Memorial Essay Jaablpur in the month of May annually.

After Indira Gandhi lost the elections ofthe ruling Janata Party wanted him to head the Commission of Inquiry against the illegal imposition of the emergency and the various atrocities committed during it jabalpuur Khanna refused, as he felt he would appear biased mabalpur Indira Gandhi and her son Sanjay Gandhi.

Retrieved from ” https: In the end, he quoted Justice Charles Evans Hughes:. He was then offered the Chairmanship of the Finance Commissiona position he also refused.

Hans Raj Khanna

Therefore, the state need not furnish the reason for dentation. Verma and B G Verghese.

However, Justice Khanna resisted the pressure to concur with this majority view. The Government of the day decided to appeal against the decisions of the High Courts in the Supreme Court, which later became famous and known as the Additional District Magistrate of Jabalpur vs.

ADM Jabalpur vs Shivkant Shukla () 2 SCC – Case Summary

Views Read Edit View history. Eastern Book Co, Lucknow, Nani Palkhivala’s book, which come out soon after the emergency asm revoked, carried a full-fledged chapter on him titled, “Salute to Justice Khanna”.

RayJustice M.